« Parent, Party Prep, and Painting WeekendForgetting Sarah Marshall (2008) »

May 1, 2008

Expelled: No Intelligence Allowed (2008)

Ric and the Agadonis and I went to an event at the university where Expelled was supposedly going to be screened, only to find out that it was Ben Stein in person talking about the movie. It ended up being an interesting event, but we were all disappointed that we would have to shell out another $10 to see the movie. Oh well.

The documentary is about how people in the scientific world of academia who even mention or consider the idea of intelligent design as an explanation for the origin of life are basically being blacklisted. Ben Stein interviews several people who have experienced unfair treatment. He goes on to interview experts in the field of ID and also experts in the field of evolution. He then explores the arguments of both sides.

Overall, I thought the movie was thought-provoking. I didn't care for the old footage (there are several clips of old movies) at all and worry that the movie's exploration of the Darwinian extremes (Hitler, communism) will come across as fanatical. I think that's probably why the movie is receiving poor marks from the critics.

Oh yeah, did I mention there's a scene of Ben Stein on our campus, walking in front of the 50 foot Jesus? That whole scene was like one big advertisement for our school.

I think Ben Stein's intentions were better revealed to us at the event we went to at the university, and Expelled actually meanders more than I would like. Personally, I didn't think the movie needed to be about Intelligent Design vs. Darwinism. A film is far too short a forum for discussing such big topics, although I admit that Stein addressed more than I thought he would. If he, like he did at the university event, had focused solely on the idea of people being Expelled because of their own academic inquiry, I think it would resonate more with audiences and make a bigger impact as well.

Even so, it was interesting and sometimes amusing, and a good conversation starter, to say the least.

Posted by Jeri Email at 04:06:55 pm | movies, 2008 | 3 comments »

3 comments

Comment from: mr. magoo [Visitor] Email · http://roadtovalinor.blogspot.com
I haven't seen it yet, but would be interested what you think about that "Expelled Exposed" website Brendo referenced on his blog.
05/01/08 @ 21:07
Comment from: brendoman [Member] Email · http://brendoman.com
I saw the movie and read the site and it's pretty obvious that they both have their agendas. The site brings up some good points, but so does the film. I just think it could have been done in a much better way. I do have a bias against Ben Stein though ever since I read about all his work he did for the Nixon administration and how he continues to defend him. For some people, that isn't a problem, but for me that says a lot about his character.
05/01/08 @ 22:09
Comment from: Jeri [Member] Email
I haven't visited the site but have heard several arguments about the movie already. I'm the first to admit that it's a flawed movie, but do believe it has a lot of valid points.

As for the Nixon thing, well, I pretty much am against the doings of most stars in Hollywood, so I don't see it too differently. Funny you should mention it, though, because when he came to the school he received an award, and some of us were wondering how wise it was of the school to show support of him since he isn't always showing the values that the school is supposed to represent.

At any rate, his speech writing capabilities are amazing, and although the event was a bit like preaching to the choir (actually, it reminded me of a state of the union address with all of the interruptions for applause), he gave a heck of a speech that was better in style than any I have heard so far from our presidential candidates.
05/02/08 @ 08:11

Leave a comment


Your email address will not be revealed on this site.

Your URL will be displayed.
(Line breaks become <br />)
(Name, email & website)
(Allow users to contact you through a message form (your email will not be revealed.)

You can just use your OpenID to provide your name, e-mail and url.