« Poll: How did your 2009 taxes compare to 2008?NOTY Final Four »

04/15/09

Solo triangle? Seriously?

Filed under: Music, NewsKyle Email @ 11:53:13 am

When I heard this story on NPR yesterday I seriously considered, for a long time, that it may be a joke. Even though it wasn't April Fool's Day and there wasn't anything about the story (aside from its ridiculousness) that would indicate as such, I just kept thinking that these people can't be serious.

The story is about a woman who has recorded a CD of solo triangle music. Yes, you read that correctly and it is exactly what it claims to be: one person, playing the triangle. For 55 minutes.

I think that what made me disbelieve the story so much is not just the idea of someone recording solo triangle, but the unabashed enthusiasm Melissa Block expresses for the music. It really seems like a parody of the way that NPR embraces overlooked cultures and artforms of all types.

At one point Block says, "It's hard to imagine that nobody thought of an idea this--" and I immediately thought in my head "stupid? or simple?" but she finishes "--this great before."

Really, Melissa?

There are so many quotes in the story that are unintentionally funny, it's hard to pick a favorite. Is it when the musician gets "carried away" with the power of the music and yelps aloud? Or when Melissa Block mentions how the CD cover "undersells" the albums by advertising over 45 minutes of music?

No, my favorite part was this bit:

"I think a less discriminating listener might hear track #1, L’Anse au Paille...[plays a few seconds of a quickly repeating rhythm]...and you might then listen to track #3, La Port en Arrière...[plays, I swear, the same fricking rhythm]...you could think that was the exact same song, or even the same song as track #4, Blues de Port Arthur...[again plays the same rhythm]"

Of course the producer explains how despite their similarities they really are individual songs with subtle nuances, but by that time they had completely lost me.

Even after I got home and told Erika about this story, we agreed that it had to be a joke, so I decided to Google it.

Apparently it's real.

4 comments

Comment from: Lonnie [Visitor] · http://idtmi.blogspot.com
I'm glad you checked if this was real, because I had exactly the same thoughts when I head the story yesterday.

"Wait, this can't be real."

I kept asking The Girl if she thought they were doing a late April Fools thing or something. The bit about a less discerning listener thinking some of the tracks sounded the same was hilarious.

Melissa Block had to be laughing on the inside if not out.

The bit about the triangle player playing her family song and getting into it so much that she started calling out was a classic.
04/15/09 @ 17:08
Comment from: Andrew [Member] Email · http://www.brendoman.com/andrew
This reminds me of a segment I heard on NPR a good 10 years ago about a guy who recorded an album of "washboard music," and spent a lot of time effusing about how great his washboard playing was. The thing is, the clips they played sounded like a straight-up bluegrass album, and if there was any washboard in it at all, I didn't hear it!
04/15/09 @ 20:00
Comment from: Ellen [Visitor] · http://nesperland.blogspot.com
LOL!! That is so funny.
04/16/09 @ 21:03
Comment from: Ellen [Visitor] · http://nesperland.blogspot.com
Okay--just read the link and though the album is real, the idea is clearly meant to be a joke. It's a good one :)
04/16/09 @ 21:06

Comments are closed for this post.